Review

Carrie Season 1 Review: Mike Flanagan Gives a Horror Classic New Life

Mike Flanagan's Carrie went from an 8/10 premiere to a 9/10 season, and gave Carrie White something she's never had before: a future. Spoilers ahead.

9/10

Essential

Nerd Crave rating

By Luey Hernandez 8 min read
Summer H. Howell as Carrie White, covered in blood and wearing a tiara at prom in Prime Video's Carrie
Summer H. Howell as Carrie White. Image: Prime Video

Nerd Crave Score: 9/10 – Essential

Spoiler Warning: This review discusses major events from all eight episodes of Carrie, including the prom massacre, character deaths and the season finale.

The Summary

When I reviewed the first episode of Mike Flanagan’s Carrie, I gave it an 8/10 and asked one question: are we watching the beginning of a horror version of X-Men?

Eight episodes later, I couldn’t be happier that the series followed through.

Flanagan hasn’t just modernized Carrie White’s story. He’s given her a future.

Stephen King’s original works because it’s a self-contained tragedy, and some fans will always prefer it that way. But this version keeps what made that story iconic while adding new relationships, mysteries and supernatural possibilities that expand Carrie’s story well beyond prom night. Add an outstanding cast led by Summer H. Howell and Samantha Sloyan, and Carrie became one of the most compelling series I’ve watched this year.

Summer H. Howell Makes Carrie Her Own

Summer H. Howell as Carrie White holding a book in a crowded high school hallway
Summer H. Howell as Carrie White. Image: Prime Video

Howell delivers exactly the performance this reinterpretation needed.

Her Carrie isn’t just shy. She’s someone who has been isolated from the world almost her entire life, trying to figure out things other teenagers take for granted. That innocence makes the cruelty she faces hard to watch, and even as her powers grow, Howell never loses the vulnerability that keeps Carrie human.

I also respect how she approached the role. Howell chose not to watch the original movie before playing Carrie. Some fans will knock that, but I believe a new performance doesn’t always benefit from imitation. Howells Carrie feels like her own, not a Sissy Spacek recreation, and that matters a lot for a version that takes the character somewhere new.

Samantha Sloyan Makes Margaret More Than a Villain

Summer H. Howell as Carrie White standing beside Samantha Sloyan as Margaret White
Summer H. Howell and Samantha Sloyan as Carrie and Margaret White. Image: Prime Video

As much as I loved Howell, Samantha Sloyan is just as phenomenal as Margaret White.

I’ve admired her since she played Bev Keane in Midnight Mass. Nobody plays someone completely convinced of their beliefs like she does, even when those beliefs lead somewhere destructive.

What makes her Margaret fascinating is that I never saw her as someone who hated her daughter. I saw a mother who loves Carrie, but whose fear of the outside world has become tangled up with what she thinks motherhood is.

The prayer closet says it all. Every time Carrie pushes back, Margaret turns religion into punishment. For me, faith should be about love, grace and forgiveness. Margaret’s version runs almost entirely on fear, and instead of bringing Carrie closer, it pushes her further away.

Sloyan also lets us see the doubt underneath. There are moments where Margaret seems to know she’s hurting their relationship, but she keeps falling back on the only kind of protection she understands. That doesn’t excuse the abuse, but it does make her a far more complicated character.

One of my favorite ideas in the season is that Carrie and Margaret are fighting opposite versions of the same problem. Carrie wants to escape isolation. Margaret has spent years escaping the world. When she’s forced back into it, she starts discovering she can actually influence the people around her.

That’s why the school meeting about prom surprised me. I really thought Margaret was going to stand up for it, but instead, she argues against it. It felt like a missed moment for mother and daughter win that i was desperately wanting in the series, but it also shows how hard change is for some people.

The Supporting Cast Makes the Cruelty Personal

Close-up of Summer H. Howell as a worried Carrie White in a school gym
Summer H. Howell as Carrie White. Image: Prime Video

Alison Thornton is incredibly convincing as Chris Hargensen. You know a villain performance is working when you can’t stand the character, the way we all felt about Draco Malfoy or Joffrey. I disliked Chris every second she was on screen, and that’s a credit to Thornton.

I also wondered if Chris’s cruelty came partly from jealousy. She has popularity, money and influence, but she’s miserable. Carrie makes her own clothes and doesn’t care about status. Maybe the things Chris mocks are things she wishes she could be. That doesn’t excuse her, but it does make her downfall more tragic.

Siena Agudong plays Sue Snell well, but Sue stayed one of my least favorite characters. She’s uncertain, self-centered and careless with people, especially Tommy. Her best moment is when she records Chris and takes the evidence to the school. That was the only real moment of growth i felt from her character, and even I still wasn’t fully sold on her friendship with Carrie.

Joel Oulette brings real compassion to Tommy Ross. I never read his relationship with Carrie as a romance. I believe he had plenty going on in his own life, and his kindness toward her felt sincere. His death hurts because he was one of the few who actually cared, but for me it wasn’t the emotional center of the finale. I was more invested in what prom would do to Carrie.

Emaline West Changes Everything

If one addition completely changed my interest in Carrie, it’s Emaline West, played by Thalia Dudek.

She first shows up as someone who understands what Carrie is going through. By the finale, we learn she’s an astral projector who can appear elsewhere and even take control of Carrie’s body.

It complicates the question of responsibility in a great way. Carrie doesn’t direct every act of violence that night, but she isn’t completely innocent either. Her confrontation with Chris and Billy afterward is her own choice.

I still believe there’s a lot of humanity in Carrie. What worries me is who’s influencing her. Carrie spent her life with a mother who told her to fear the world. Now she may be listening to someone telling her the world belongs to her. Neither one gives her what she actually needs to evolve.

A Horror Version of X-Men? The Comparison Still Works

One thing I love about comics is the idea that extraordinary people exist in a world much bigger than their own story. That’s why the finale’s reveals got me so excited.

Margaret has telekinesis of her own. Emaline has a completely different gift. And there are other mysterious women with abilities, plus people hunting them. Suddenly Carrie isn’t one isolated girl with powers. She’s part of a world where others understand those powers better than she does.

As an X-Men fan, I keep coming back to mentorship. Jean Grey is at her most dangerous when emotions or outside influences get between her and her power. (We just saw that play out in Spider-Man: Brand New Day.) Carrie could face the same thing. With the right guidance, she could learn to protect instead of destroy. With the wrong influence, she could become extraordinarily dangerous.

And then there’s Stephen King’s bigger picture. Flanagan has said Carrie exists “on a certain level of the Tower,” and he’s attached to adapt The Dark Tower. I could easily see him becoming the Kevin Feige of Stephen King adaptations. That’s pure speculation, since no connected universe has been announced, but as someone who loves connected storytelling, I’m all in.

What I Wish Season 1 Explored More

I didn’t have many complaints, but a few things held it back for me.

  • Ralph White. In my Episode 1 review, I wondered why Carrie and Margaret didn’t seem to grieve him. The season showed they do miss him, but I still wanted more about his history and how his conspiracy-driven worldview shaped their isolated life.
  • The rest of Carrie’s family. Grandparents? Aunts? Anyone before public school? The show never really says.
  • The teacher subplot. The abusive teacher-student relationship is a serious issue, and I get its tie to the school’s social media scandal, but it took time away from Carrie’s journey.
  • Tina Blake. Josie Totah plays her convincingly. I just found the character more irritating than interesting.

Some of the bullying also felt exaggerated, even though I know real-world harassment can be just as cruel. And I’d love more on the other gifted women and the people hunting them, though that mystery clearly belongs to Season 2.

Why Carrie Deserves a Different Ending

Summer H. Howell as Carrie White smiling in a tiara and pale dress after being crowned prom queen
Carrie White, prom queen. Image: Prime Video

The biggest creative swing Flanagan took was letting Carrie White survive.

She’s been isolated, humiliated, manipulated and pushed past her limits. She’s made terrible decisions, and she’ll have to live with them. But that doesn’t mean her story has to end in despair.

Whether it’s comics, anime, games or film, one thing I love about the stories we care about is that they can show us hardship doesn’t have to be the end. A hopeful ending still has to be earned. But I’d love to see Carrie understand her abilities, face her trauma and find people who care about her without trying to control her.

The Nerd Crave Verdict: 9/10 – Essential

Mike Flanagan’s Carrie exceeded my expectations.

Howell gives Carrie White a fresh identity, Sloyan brings incredible depth to Margaret, the supporting cast is excellent, and the modern take on bullying feels painfully relevant. But what impressed me most was the expanded mythology. From that first episode, I suspected Carrie’s powers were part of something bigger, and watching that pay off was incredibly satisfying.

Not every storyline got the attention it deserved, but I found very little to dislike. What started as an 8/10 premiere became a 9/10 season.

And now that Prime Video has officially renewed it for Season 2, I want to see whether Carrie meets people who can challenge her, and whether she finds the guidance to become a better version of herself. I don’t need her to become a superhero. After everything she’s been through, I just want her to have a future worth looking forward to.

Now I want to hear from you: Did the expanded mythology work for you, or do you prefer Stephen King’s original tragedy?

Where to Watch

All eight episodes of Carrie are streaming now on Prime Video. Into horror that goes beyond jump scares? Check out Marvel’s Midnight Universe.

Stay Curious. Feed the Crave.

Carrie Mike Flanagan Prime Video Stephen King